Three Stone vs. Solitaire Engagement Ring: Which Style Tells Your Story Best?

Choosing an engagement ring isn't just about picking a style; it's about capturing your love story in a piece of jewelry that will last a lifetime. When it comes to engagement rings, couples tend to choose between two designs: the iconic solitaire and the symbolic three stone ring. The former is known for its striking simplicity, while the latter is celebrated for its deep symbolism. Both are timeless and everlasting, so how are you to choose? 

In this guide, we'll walk you through key differences between these beloved styles, so you can confidently choose the ring that speaks to your style, values, and future together. 

Key Takeaways 

• Solitaire engagement rings highlight a single diamond, offering timeless elegance and minimalist beauty 

• Three stone engagement rings carry symbolic weight, with each stone representing the past, present, or future

• Three stone styles often cost more due to added stones and complexity, but offer more opportunities for personalization 

• Solitaire rings tend to be easier to clean, maintain, and pair with a wedding band 

• Both styles can be customized, giving you flexibility in all aspects
  
  

Understanding Solitaire Engagement Rings

There's a reason solitaire engagement rings have never gone out of style. With one beautiful diamond as the star of the show, these rings embody refined simplicity. A solitaire engagement ring places all of the attention on a single center stone, which lets the cut, clarity, and sparkle speak volumes without distraction. 

The beauty of a solitaire ring is that it is a blank canvas. Whether you are drawn to traditional styles or want a more modern look, the versatility of the solitaire ring ensures that it works with any aesthetic. It truly is the little black dress of the jewelry world: effortless, iconic, and always appropriate.

A Brief History of the Solitaire Ring

The solitaire style owes its current popularity to Tiffany & Co., who introduced their signature setting back in 1886. By lifting the one stone above the band, it allowed more light to pass through the diamond, which created breathtaking brilliance. That design set the standard for solitaire engagement rings and is still widely used today.

Over the years the solitaire has become iconic. For couples who want a ring that will never feel dated, the solitaire remains one of the most trusted choices. It has passed the test of time and has become the quintessential standard for engagement rings. 

Popular Solitaire Ring Settings

Classic Six-Prong Setting

Timeless and Secure. This setting balances security and sparkle. The six prongs ensure the diamond stays in place while still allowing plenty of light to pass through the stone.

Cathedral Setting

Elegant with Vintage Flair. Arched shoulders rise to support the center stone, adding height and drama to the design. 

Bezel Setting

Sleek and Smooth. This setting wraps entirely around the diamond, protecting it while giving the ring a modern, streamlined profile. A great choice for active lifestyles.

 

Tension Setting

Striking and Modern. With the diamond suspended between the ends of the band, this architectural style delivers bold visual impact and often a few double takes. 

Four-Prong Setting

Brilliant and Open. Though it may seem subtle, switching from six prongs to four allows more light to hit the stone, boosting its brilliance and fire. 

Why Choose a Solitaire? 

Solitaire engagement rings speak to couples who appreciate understated luxury, clean lines, and classic design. They are easy to pair with wedding bands, easy to clean, and allow you to focus on other details like the quality of the stone or personalizing the band to fit your needs. 

Exploring Three Stone Engagement Rings

If you find yourself drawn to symbolism and sparkle, a three stone engagement ring may be the perfect fit. This beloved style represents your shared journey, with each stone symbolizing the past, present, and future of your relationship.

More than just visually striking, three stone rings tell a story. Each diamond tells a part of your story, connecting on a deeper level with couples who want their ring to reflect meaning as well as beauty.

Design Possibilities: One Style, Endless Variations

While the concept remains the same, three stone engagement ring designs are almost endlessly customizable. Traditionally, the style features a larger center stone flanked by two smaller diamonds, but there’s no one-size-fits-all.

 

Classic Proportions

A center stone twice the size of the side stones draws the eye to the heart of the ring while adding depth and dimension.

Equal-Sized Stones

For a modern twist, three identical stones offer striking symmetry and a bold, balanced look on the finger.

Mixed Gemstones

Personalize your ring with birthstones, colored diamonds, or meaningful gems for a one-of-a-kind design that reflects your style and story.

Varied Cuts and Shapes

While the round center stone and round side stones are beautiful, creating intrigue with tapered baguettes or pear-shaped stones creates visual intrigue and an artistic touch.

Modern Interpretations

Your three stone ring doesn’t have to look like anyone else’s. Asymmetry, unexpected stones, and bold settings let you create a ring that feels uniquely you.

Why Choose a Three Stone Ring?

For many couples, the meaning behind this design is its biggest draw. The three stones celebrate where you’ve been, where you are, and where you’re going. These rings are a physical reminder and an enduring symbol of love, growth, and commitment.

When paired with nearly limitless design possibilities, the three stone ring stands above the rest. From the stone shapes to the color palette to the proportions, every element can be tailored to fit your style. If you're looking for an engagement ring that blends sentiment with standout beauty, a three stone ring is your best bet.

Solitaire vs. Three Stone Engagement Rings: How They Compare

Now that you know the unique appeal of each ring style, let’s take a closer look at how they stack up in the categories that matter most to couples shopping for engagement rings.

Style & Aesthetic

Solitaire rings are loved for their clean lines and understated elegance. They pair beautifully with any outfit and are great for everyday wear and occasions. The focus stays on the diamond, which makes the quality and cut of the stone especially important.

Three stone rings, by contrast, make a bold impression. With more sparkle and dimension, they offer a sense of richness and depth. They are seen more of a statement piece and tend to overshadow other jewelry being worn. These rings often feel more romantic or meaningful, since each stone is tied to a moment in your relationship. 

Symbolism

Solitaire rings symbolize clarity, commitment, and a single focus on love. Their simplicity speaks volumes, making them a popular choice for traditionalists and minimalists alike.

Three stone rings carry deeper symbolic meaning. By honoring the past, celebrating the present, and looking ahead to the future, this design adds emotional weight to an already meaningful piece of jewelry.

Customization Options

Both styles offer room for creativity, but in different ways. Solitaires are easy to personalize through band details, metal choice, or unique prong styles. They also make a great starting point for those who may want to add an enhancer or custom wedding band later on.

Three stone rings offer more ways to play with proportions, shapes, and gemstones. You can vary the size or cut of each stone, incorporate birthstones or colored gems, or experiment with asymmetry. This makes the three stone design a favorite for those who want a one-of-a-kind look.

Practicality & Maintenance

Solitaires are generally easier to clean and maintain. With fewer stones and settings to care for, they can be a great option for someone with an active lifestyle or who prefers low-maintenance jewelry.

Three stone rings require more upkeep because of the additional stones and settings. However, many feel the added sparkle is well worth the extra care.

Both rings require regular maintenance and cleaning both at home and by professionals. This ensures the longevity of your rings and keeps any damage to a minimum.

Price Range

Solitaire engagement rings are typically more affordable, especially if you are focusing on a single high-quality diamond. They are a great way to maximize your budget while still choosing a timeless and elegant design.

Three stone rings usually cost more due to the extra diamonds and more complex settings. However, the added investment often results in a ring that feels even more special and personalized.

Final Thoughts: Choosing What’s Right for You

Whether you're drawn to the timeless simplicity of a solitaire or the meaningful sparkle of a three stone ring, the most important thing is that your engagement ring feels like you. At Frank Jewelers, we believe your ring should be as unique and lasting as the love it represents.

Solitaire rings offer elegance in its purest form, perfect for those who value clean design and enduring style. Three stone rings, on the other hand, invite symbolism and creativity, telling a deeper story through every facet. Neither choice is “better.” Picking out a ring is all about finding the one that speaks to your heart and your future together.

If you're still unsure which style is right for you, we're always excited to help. Visit us in-store or explore our collection online to try on styles, ask questions, and design the ring that tells your story best.